Skip to main content
MoneyEnergy

Michigan's New Data Center "Information" Coalition Has the Hallmarks of an Astroturf Campaign

Rhinoceros Newsroom6 min
Part 4 of 6The Chamber Network
Contents
  1. A PR Firm Manages the Website
  2. The Same Firm Represents a Data Center Developer
  3. The "Independent" Economic Analysis
  4. The University of Michigan Guidebook
  5. What the Coalition Does Not Disclose
  6. Who Benefits
  7. Preliminary Findings: Governance Overlap
  8. Methodology

LANSING, Mich. — Michigan for Responsible Data Centers, a 17-member coalition that launched March 19, says it is committed to providing "clear, accurate information about data centers" to Michigan communities. The website names no individuals and lists no contact information of any kind. Publicly available records show that a PR firm representing a data center developer manages the site's content, and that the economic research the coalition cites as independent was paid for by one of its own members.

A PR Firm Manages the Website

Publicly accessible metadata on the MRDC website identifies two user accounts. One belongs to a freelance web developer with no political or industry affiliations who built the site structure. The other, with the username apoole, authored all five blog posts and uploaded all 24 media files on the site, including stock photographs and a Consumers Energy document.

A digital fingerprint associated with the apoole account matches the email address apoole@bellwetherpr.com. Bellwether's team page lists Andie Poole, APR, as a Partner. Her email is apoole@bellwetherpr.com.

Comparison showing a digital fingerprint from the MRDC website matching the email address apoole@bellwetherpr.com
A digital fingerprint associated with the MRDC content author account matches Andie Poole's Bellwether PR email address. Source: publicly accessible website metadata, accessed March 20, 2026.

Poole is the sole content author on the site. The site's RSS feed and author sitemap both confirm this. The entire site was built in a single day, eight days after the domain was registered. Two of the five blog posts carry dates from 2025, before the domain existed. They are reposted articles from other publications, displayed under their original publication dates rather than the date they were added to the site.

The Same Firm Represents a Data Center Developer

Bellwether PR was retained by Deep Green Technologies for communications work related to the company's proposed data center in downtown Lansing, according to WKAR reporting from January 16, 2026. Bellwether partner Josh Hovey spoke at the November 5, 2025 Lansing Planning Commission meeting as Deep Green's PR representative.

The coalition's website does not mention Bellwether PR or its relationship with Deep Green Technologies.

The "Independent" Economic Analysis

MRDC's March 19 press release cites economic research by Anderson Economic Group (AEG), an East Lansing consulting firm. The research claims data center development could generate $121 million to $5.5 billion in construction economic output and 806 to 30,000 construction jobs.

Three facts about this research are not mentioned in the press release:

  1. The analysis was commissioned by Consumers Energy, which is itself an MRDC coalition member.
  2. The press contact listed on AEG's website for the data center analysis is Bridgette Bauer (bbauer@bellwetherpr.com), a Public Affairs Manager at Bellwether PR. Bellwether manages the press for the research and manages the website that cites it.
  3. Anderson Economic Group is listed as a client of Andie Poole on Bellwether's team page. AEG is also an MRDC coalition member.

To summarize: Consumers Energy paid for the research. Bellwether PR handles the research's press. Bellwether PR also manages the coalition website where the research is cited. And AEG, the firm that produced the research, is both a Bellwether client and a coalition member.

Diagram showing the circular relationship: Consumers Energy pays for AEG research, Bellwether PR manages AEG's press, Bellwether PR manages MRDC website, MRDC cites AEG research as independent, Consumers Energy is an MRDC coalition member
Financial and operational relationships between Consumers Energy, Anderson Economic Group, Bellwether PR, and Michigan for Responsible Data Centers. Sources: andersoneconomicgroup.com, bellwetherpr.com/team/, mifordatacenters.org. All accessed March 20, 2026.

The University of Michigan Guidebook

MRDC launched simultaneously with a University of Michigan Graham Sustainability Institute publication titled "What Michigan Local Governments Should Know About Data Centers," authored by Sarah Mills, PhD, and research assistant Ann Wilkinson.

The guidebook's reviewers include Brandon Hofmeister of Consumers Energy and Daniel Mahoney of DTE Energy. Both Consumers Energy and DTE Energy are MRDC coalition members. The guidebook does not disclose its funding source.

The document was created using Canva, a design tool common in PR and marketing work, rather than academic publishing software. It was finished 11 days before the MRDC domain was registered, and released the same day as the coalition's press release.

What the Coalition Does Not Disclose

The MRDC website names 17 member organizations. It does not name any individuals. There is no staff page, no board of directors, no media contact, no phone number, and no physical address. The press release quotes three coalition members by name (Jim Holcomb of the Michigan Chamber, Randy Thelen of The Right Place, and Jeff Jaros of NTH Consultants) but does not identify a spokesperson or organizational contact for the coalition itself.

There is no Michigan entity registration for "Michigan for Responsible Data Centers" in the LARA business registry as of March 20, 2026. The coalition may operate under the legal umbrella of a member organization.

The domain was registered on February 17, 2026, and the entire website was built in a single day. By March 19, the coalition had 17 members, an economic analysis, a university guidebook, and a coordinated press release ready for simultaneous release.

Who Benefits

The coalition's 17 members include two electric utilities that would sell power to data centers (Consumers Energy and DTE Energy), six building trades unions whose members would construct them, four chambers of commerce, two economic development organizations, and two engineering and construction firms that would bid on the work. Every member stands to benefit financially from increased data center development in Michigan.

The MRDC website does not describe any of these financial interests. It describes the coalition as committed to providing "clear, accurate information."

Preliminary Findings: Governance Overlap

A preliminary review of publicly available board rosters and campaign finance records suggests additional connections between MRDC coalition members and the public officials who approve data center projects. This analysis is ongoing, and these findings should be understood as initial observations, not final conclusions.

LEAP's board of directors, published on its website, includes approximately 86 members. Among them:

  • Andy Schor, Mayor of Lansing, who championed the Deep Green data center proposal that went before the Lansing City Council in late 2025
  • Tim Daman, President and CEO of the Lansing Regional Chamber of Commerce, which is both an MRDC coalition member and the operator of the LRC-PAC (MiTN Committee 000516), a political action committee that has endorsed and funded Lansing City Council candidates
  • Dick Peffley, General Manager of the Lansing Board of Water and Light, the municipal utility that would provide electricity to any data center built in the Lansing service area
  • Jessica Tramontana, Community Affairs Manager at Consumers Energy, another MRDC coalition member and the company that commissioned the AEG economic analysis cited by the coalition

These four individuals serve together on the board of an MRDC coalition member. Overlapping board seats do not by themselves establish coordination, but the pattern is worth noting: the officials who approve data center projects, the utilities that would profit from them, and the organizations that fund council campaigns all share governance of the same economic development entity.

A more detailed analysis of coalition member financial relationships, political contributions, and governance connections is forthcoming.


Methodology

This analysis is based entirely on publicly accessible information: website metadata, publicly accessible data endpoints, corporate team pages, news reporting, document properties, domain registration records, and state business registry searches. All sources were accessed between March 19-20, 2026. Every factual claim can be independently verified using the links provided.

More from Money

All Money
MoneyHousing

Federal Housing Dollars in Lansing: The Network Around the LHC

Rhinoceros NewsroomApr 26, 2026

Roughly $200 million in federal Low-Income Housing Tax Credits flow through LHC's Lansing-area development pipeline, plus federal voucher subsidies for 2,252 households. The pipeline moves through a small cluster of nonprofit, private, and law-firm entities and a recurring set of individuals who hold multiple roles across them. LHC Board Chair Emma Henry earns $123,787 a year as Executive Director of Capital Area Housing Partnership, the nonprofit named as partner on LHC LIHTC deals her board approves. Commissioner Ashlee Barker is paid Vice President at Cinnaire, the financial institution the LHC executive director identified as the standing purchaser of LHC's tax credits. The 2024 LHC board minutes record one Henry abstention out of fifteen-plus substantive resolutions, and zero Barker recusals across eight 2024 board meetings.

MoneyHousing

LHC Executive Director's Five LLCs

Rhinoceros NewsroomApr 26, 2026

The Lansing Housing Commission's executive director, Doug Fleming, is the registered agent and organizing member of at least five private Michigan business entities, four of them registered at the LHC office at 419 Cherry Street. Two are general-partner LLCs — Oliver Gardens GP, LLC and 220 Kalamazoo GP, LLC — that collect developer fees on Low-Income Housing Tax Credit partnerships in which LHC is the limited partner. On August 22, 2025, in a single LARA filing, Fleming signed the formation documents for Oliver Gardens II LDHA LP twice: once on behalf of Oliver Gardens GP, LLC (which he had organized one day earlier) and once on behalf of LHC. The partnership received $1,479,466 in federal LIHTC in October 2025.

HousingMoney

From Public Housing to Wall Street Mortgages: The Lansing Scattered-Site Sale

Rhinoceros NewsroomApr 25, 2026

In April 2023, the Lansing Housing Commission completed the sale of 202 scattered-site public-housing homes to a Michigan LLC formed thirteen months earlier, for $14.62 million across four closings. The buyer was renamed from SK Investments Group LLC to Red Michigan Holdings LLC eight months before the first closing, breaking name-based searches. Within nine months, $8.73 million in mortgages were assigned through Goldman Sachs to U.S. Bank Trust as trustee of Legacy Mortgage Asset Trust 2024.